top of page

10 Craigslist Selling Secrets the Pros Don't Want You to Know

Updated: Apr 22, 2023



Craigslist is a popular online marketplace, known for its vast range of products and services. While it may seem straightforward to list and sell items on Craigslist, there are several lesser-known tips and strategies that can make your selling experience more successful. In this blog post, we'll reveal insider tips that no one else will tell you.


Timing is Everything:


Consider listing your item during the weekend or after typical working hours when most people have free time to browse and respond to listings. Moreover, Friday is typically pay day, so people have more money. Our analysis suggests that posting on a Thursday evening or Friday increases the likelihood of your item being seen and sold quickly.


Optimize Your Title:


Create an eye-catching and informative title using relevant keywords and specific details about the item's features or condition. Avoid using all caps or excessive punctuation. Listings with clear, concise titles receive a higher click-through rate compared to those with vague or exaggerated titles.


Haggle on Calls and Not on Text Messages:


Let calls go to voicemail, then immediately return them, mentioning you were speaking with another potential buyer. Inquire about their availability and suggest that another buyer is also interested in the item. This tactic encourages buyers to hurry over with cash in hand. If this doesn't work, mention that someone else is en route and that you'll call back if they don't show up. When you call back after 15 minutes, they'll likely be eager to head over.


Handle Lowball Offers with Composure:


Maintain your composure when dealing with lowball offers. Sometimes, these individuals are merely testing the waters. Remain silent when someone offers a significantly lower price than your asking amount, as they might return with a more reasonable proposal.


Play the "Uninformed" Card:


Particularly when selling non-functioning items, try saying something like, "I bought it like this, I don't work on engines, it's been sitting here since I got it, I'm sure you can fix it." This approach often prompts them to confidently assert their ability to repair the item and agree to your higher asking price.


Use a Separate Email for Transactions:


By using a separate email and not your main e-mail, you can avoid potential harassment on your personal social media accounts if a buyer experiences issues and tries to contact you for a refund.


There is No Substitute for Good Photos.


Make sure you have proper lighting and a quality camera to showcase your item's features and condition. Flashy stuff with good photos sells.


Be Clear and Concise in Your Ad:


Use proper grammar, spelling, and punctuation in your listing. Potential buyers may pass on the opportunity if they struggle to decipher the language in your ad.


Use the Power of Storytelling:


Share a brief story about the item's history or how it has been used to create an emotional connection between potential buyers and the item, increasing their likelihood of making a purchase.


Provide Detailed Descriptions:


Provide a thorough description of your item, mentioning any unique features, potential uses, and specific details about its condition.


Bonus Tip


Leverage Buyer Travel Distance:


How far away are you coming from? This should be one of the first questions you ask the buyer. The greater the distance a buyer has to travel, the more likely they are to make the purchase. They won't want to return empty-handed after a long trip. For example, you may be able to sell a subpar motorcycle at your desired price if the buyer has driven a considerable distance to see it.


By implementing these 10 valuable tips, you can greatly enhance your selling experience on Craigslist. As you apply these strategies, you'll navigate the platform more efficiently, negotiate better deals, and ultimately secure successful sales.


Need Help Writing Craigslist item descriptions that will make you the most money? We are here to help!


We wrote a guide on how to write the most effective online market place descriptions here.

Comments


bottom of page